John withheld important information whether it was about Jamies mother being a Dutton, Evelyns sister, or whatever other reason Jamie has a privileged position as as an adopted son. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Flashbacks have revealed that Evelyn was not the gentlest mother, after all, and the depth of her bond with Jamie is as yet unclear. But this just highlights what a lost soul Jamie is. Upon being released from jail, Garrett tells Jamie that he k*lled his mother to save Jamies life. Only problem is I cant imagine if a man murdered John Duttons sister he would still be living. She was heartbroken after Peter passed away and never tried to have children again. As a result of being ostracized by his family, he has certainly acted out a time or two. In season three, John reveals that he knew Jamie's mother Phyllis before she married Garrett Randall. His father, John Dutton II, who retired from ranching due to his ailing health, died several years later of cancer, urging him never to give up the ranch to anyone under any circumstances, which was a promise John had taken to heart. How different would Johns reaction have been if Evelyn Dutton were still alive? We shall see Maybe Jamie is from John's wife's side (his sister in law? John also told Jamie that he begged Jamies birth mother not to marry Garrett Randall because John knew what kind of man Garrett was. However, Evelyns death changed the character in a big way. Jamie's biological father beat Jamie's biological mother to death when Jamie was three-months-old. After discovering he is not a Dutton by blood, Jamie sets out looking for answers. Who Lives In It Now. It is likely that John Dutton adopted Jamie since he knew the Randall family and wanted to protect Jamie from any further harm. Save this link as we will be updating the information as more details are known and as new characters join the cast. As the only grandchild of John Dutton III, he is the heir apparent to the family land. After some time, Garrett is able to bond with his son, expressing that he is proud of him. The two got engaged and were married by the ship captain after their harrowing time at sea. Led by patriarch John Dutton (Kevin Costner), the values of the family gear more towards the rustic day-to-day trials of being a ranch owner rather than Jamie's corporate lifestyle. He lost his life after trying to take the cattle back from the Broken Rock Reservation. This leads to remorse and acceptance back into the Yellowstone crew for the cycle to start over again with a different character. Evelyn may have convinced John to take Jamie in because he is family and continues to care for him to honor his wife. Yellowstone fans found out in season 3 that Jamie was adopted by John and Evelyn Dutton when he was just three months old. It is likely that John Dutton adopted Jamie since he knew the Randall family and wanted to protect Jamie from any further harm. If the Dutton side ends up being true these quotes could be a result of John being stubborn, and hardened against his degenerate sister and murderer husband. Its land. One of the horses fell over and crushed her. Upon learning that Governor Perry was making a run for the United States Senate, he was offered a potential endorsement for the Governor seat, and learned that his foster son, Jamie, who was the current state AG, was eyeing the very same prize. Bucked from her Horse and crushed due to Beth's hesitation. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. He then accosted his real dad, Garrett Randall (Will Patton), who confessed to killing Jamies mother. Jamie was born "Michael," son to an addict mother and violent father. She seems to have been especially hard on Beth. Margaret Dutton Everyone remembers Jon Snow's (Kit Harington) "Game of Thrones" reveal that he was Ned Stark's (Sean Bean) nephew, not his bastard son as he first thought. John raised Jamie as his own but he is not his biological father. But there is a war being waged against our way of life. That impacts how John sees and treats Jamie. That's when Jamie found out that the process for abortion would involve sterilization. As a result, she might have become withdrawn from the rest of her family. He inevitably realizes the information he lacked and comes crawling back to his family asking for forgiveness. One fan elaborated: I dont think she was related to them in any way, I just think because it was a small town they all knew each other and she was a friend of the family. This Family Tree Shows How the Duttons Are Related, How to Watch the 'Yellowstone' Spinoff '1883', Kelsea Ballerini Confirms Relationship With Chase, Your Privacy Choices: Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads. Powered by WordPress.com VIP. New York, But, after he was released from prison, why didn't John go after him? Other fans were quick to agree with this thought-out theory. Season 3 of Yellowstone continued with "Cowboys and Dreamers," which aired on Sunday, July 19. Those quotes definitely imply a connection between Jamies inclusion in the family and Evelyn. Yellowstone will return in 2021 on Paramount and Peacock. By my memory, Jamie has not shared any such heart-warming stories about his own childhood. My world was shaken up and how I dealt with things, I'm sure I dealt with him the same, but probably things started to bleed in. Following two succesful runs, Yellowstone returned for a third outing this year, bringing the show . His parents are James and Margaret Dutton. Hence, it is likely that John avoids talking about his mother and chooses not to share memories of his mother with his children. Yellowstone Jimmy star defends his disastrous decision in season 3, Yellowstone season 4 theories: Jamie's real mother to be unveiled as John's sister, Yellowstone: Jamie Dutton's adoption was kept hidden from him his whole life. Season 5 airing Sundays on Paramount Network beginning November 13th, 2022. The poster goes on to back up this theory with many interesting supporting elements. This popular fan theory has not been confirmed in 1923 just yet, but the death of John Dutton Sr. in Episode Three of 1923 complicated the family line down to Costner's John Dutton III. Josh Holloway salary: How much is Josh Holloway paid for Yellowstone. Yellowstone season 4 theories: Jamies real mother is Johns sister. The episode also opened with a . Beth was nervous which caused her horse to spook the horse Evelyn was riding. While Jamie continues to struggle to find his place on the ranch, this discovery could give him a greater sense of much-needed security as the Dutton family becomes increasingly fractured. Therefore, she allows Jamie to meet his son for the first time. The series is yet to name the character or address her involvement in any major events in the story. John Dutton III's brother died as an infant. SPOILERS AHEAD! Jamie was born as James Michael Randall to a couple named Garrett Randall and Phyllis Mary Randall, who had quite a rough marriage. In the fourth episode of the fifth season, titled Horses in Heaven, Costners John Dutton remembers his mother while telling Monica about his brother, Peter Dutton, who sadly passed away shortly after birth. I lean more to the Dutton side than Evelyn but either are possible. The youngest Dutton sibling (played by Luke Grimes) is torn between obligations to his father, John III, and his wife, Monica, and their son, Tate. She says no. The show seems to use Johns gruff, contemplative, and short winded nature as a plot device to withhold important information. Jamie Duttons real parents are Garrett and Phyllis Randall, and originally Jamie went by the name Michael Randall. This is Jamie Dutton's (Wes Bentley) lot in life when he is adopted by the multi-generational ranch-owning family. He and Elsa fall in love and marry in an unofficial ceremony. The episode before tonight's finale ended with two bad cowboys hired by Market Equities' Roarke (Josh Holloway) being chased down by the Dutton posse for nearly killing two Dutton ranch hands . Actor Patton has. View this post on Instagram A post shared by Wes Bentley Fan page?? I get its TV but still. (@wesbentleyfanpage) Rips story and position on the ranch should prove that Jamie is more than just an adopted son of a deadbeat. Who was Evelyn Dutton's favorite child? The series expands on the Dutton family tree through the spin-off prequel shows 1883 and 1923. The three shows include a combined four characters named John Dutton. It really would be a coincidence that Jamie got the name Jamie though but it also makes sense that it would be Evelyn's sister as the mother. Jamie's biological father was sent to prison for the murder of his mother. The story goes that Jamie's biological father murdered his mother, and . More info. Does John descend from Spencer's line and Jamie from John I and then Jack's?). a formerly convicted criminal responsible for the death of Jamie's birth mother, Phyllis, while the two were addicted to drugs. His biological father went to prison for second-degree murder, and the Duttons adopted Jamie. Garrett previously claimed that he killed Jamie's birth mother to protect Jamie, but Garrett and John's history seemed to simmer with all kinds . At the time Garrett is living on his own on a farm. After Season 3 finishes airing, this falls premieres will arrive to keep fans busy entertained as they wait for Season 4. Evelyn appears in the. I've thought along the lines that Jamie's mother was John's sister for some time now. He is just a child in 1883, but is a grown man by the events of 1923.John, along with his parents, survives the treacherous route the Dutton family takes in order to settle in Montana eventually. During a flashback scene, fans found out why Beth hates Jamie so much. Garrett became overwhelmed with anger that Jamie was put in such a dangerous situation. He said he loves his adopted son even though he has been "a disappointment and my greatest failure." Has Beth killed him? A flashback to 1997 shows Evelyn went riding with two of her children, Beth and Kayce. After Beth discovers the truth about who was behind the attack on the Duttons, she confronts Jamie. Is Daisy Jones & The Six Based on a True Story? While there is not a lot we know about Phyllis and how she knew the Duttons, many fans have their theories. He is a Montana rancher. He's married to Margaret, and they have three children: Elsa, Spencer, and John Dutton Sr. He has even strayed away from the family, searching for his birth father, Garrett Randall (Will Patton), who tries to convince him to turn against the Duttons. As a result, she might have become withdrawn from the rest of her family. He buried Evelyn on the ranch. Let her undo it. Its a pretty cruel thing to say to the young girl who obviously didnt mean for this tragedy to happen. Jamies father struggled to make ends meet, and his mother struggled with a drug addict. Redditor Luvsplants123 posted: So who do you think Jamie's real mother is? Jamie then shoots Garrett in the head and k*lls him. Furthermore, John rarely speaks about his mother making it difficult for us to understand the personality and nature of Johns mother. Evelyn Dutton was John Dutton 's wife and mother of Lee, Jamie, Beth and Kayce. In Paramount's Yellowstone, everyone knows that John Dutton III (Costner) is the head of his family. Yellowstone: What secret has Beth Dutton kept since season 1? If someone figures it out, they can let me know." Spoilers for Season 3, Episode 7 of Yellowstone entitled The Beating are discussed below. John recently learned that Jamie gave the okay for an unwitting Bet to undergo a hysterectomy as part of getting an abortion as a teen. John Dutton IV (adoptive nephew) Appears in Yellowstone No. You know, when they try it themselves. I feel like that is a whole lane that can have secrets in it we know nothing about. Could John possibly hear Jamies side and be moved by it enough to accept that there's truth beyond his own? Since Phylliss maiden name has not been revealed, we dont know who she truly is. It does need mending, though. If Jamies real mother was, in fact, Johns sister, it certainly seems like a strange thing to keep hidden now the biggest secret is out in the open. He and his wife Cara do not have children of their own, but they helped raise their nephews. The Duttons were a prominent family in the area, known for giving second chances to people who need them. She was raised on the Broken Rock Reservation and suffered a devastating accident in season 5 that resulted in the loss of her baby. I also think Evelyn (Johns wife) is the one who wanted to do it. Love this narrative. Country Living editors select each product featured. Do you think that John has treated Jamie as well as Beth and Kayce? That's all I can say. Though some fans had follow-up thoughts, no one can deny that this would be information that would blow up Jamie's life. They will tell it so much you might even start to believe it yourself. John sees in Jamie the man who took his sister from the family and then murdered her. She was heartbroken after Peter passed away and never tried to have children again. He married and started a family with Evelyn Dutton. When Jamie confronted John, the latter filled his son in on most of the details surrounding the Yellowstone secret. ---- The Duttons adopted Jamie when he was only three months old and raised him as their own. "We also don't know Jamie's mother's maiden name. Sam (Martin Sensmeier) is a Comanche warrior who encounters the Dutton family along their journey in 1883. Yellowstone centers around the Dutton family, the owners of the largest ranch in the United States. The Yellowstone Theory About Jamie's Birth Mother Would Complicate Things Even More. I find it so interesting we know nothing about John Dutton III's mother. The Yellowstone episode No Good Horses explains what happened to her. Theory: Jamie Dutton's birth mother is a Dutton John Dutton adopted Jamie even though he despises Jamie's birth father. How dare you destroy it.. Moreover, she could have been related to Johns late wife Evelyn (Gretchen Mol), who was shown to have been crushed by a horse during a tragic flashback in the first season. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. ---- I do the very best I can for my children and if they want to tell me someday why I wasn't a great father, I guess I'll listen, but you know lots of luck to them. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. . Some of the show's stars have admitted that even they are confused by the characters' relationships (and we suspect Taylor Sheridan is being intentionally cryptic about some of the connections), but fear not: We're here to clear up some of the confusion with the Dutton family tree. It's also presumed that he's the grandfather of John Dutton III (aka, Yellowstone's main character). ET on Paramount Network. After meeting his estranged biological father, some fans of the Paramount Western are convinced his journey of self-discovery is far from over. Find out how John and Jamie move past the adoption bombshell when new episodes of Yellowstone air Sundays at 9 p.m. John is the patriarch of the Dutton family and the owner of Yellowstone Dutton Ranch, the largest ranch in the United States which was located in Park, due east of Bozeman. Copyright 2023 Endgame360 Inc. All Rights Reserved. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. I am sure that John believes that in his heart, but his eyes should tell him another story. In real life, however, Costner is happily married to designer Christine Baumgartner.As per People, the actor was married to Cindy Silva until they . He is one of at least three John's in the family, the others being his son, John Dutton Jr., and his grandson, John Dutton III. She passed away on March 30th, 1997. Yellowstone season 4: Will Rip Wheeler kill Angela Blue Thunder? Jack's parents are John Sr. and Emma, and he works on the ranch with his family. Yellowstone: Jamie confronted his real father, Garrett Randall, Yellowstone season four could reveal more about the Dutton family tree, James May opens up on pretty long days filming Grand Tour, Virgin River season 3 spoilers: Lizzie and Ricky romance sealed, Lucifer fans tip season 6 time jump after episode title clues. Jamie got back in touch with wanting to work on the ranch, which he stepped away from (a bit willingly) after John called on Jamie to replace John as Livestock Commissioner. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! In the fourth episode of season 4, John explains that his mother took Peters death to heart. It was also revealed in the show that he was diagnosed with colon cancer and had a series of episodes due to the diagnosis. The self-described "tornado" has a takes-no-prisoners approach to dealing with anyone who threatens her family, including her adopted brother Jamie. After needing his birth certificate to be sworn in as the Attorney General of Montana, Jamie realized that the names on his birth certificate were not John and Evelyn Dutton like he thought for his whole life. Elizabeth (Michelle Randolph) appears in 1923 as the fianc to Jack. Jamie will find out he actually is a Dutton through his mother, John is is uncle, and john deserves to be called dad because he raised him. On the show, Dutton has been widowed for many years, as his wife died before the show's timeline began. However, nothing could be done and Evelyn died soon after. Only seen in flashbacks, Evelyn (Gretchen Mol) is John's wife and mother of Kayce, Beth, and Lee and adopted mother to Jamie. John's resentment of Jamie could come from bitterness that Jamie's father took away his sister from the ranch, which ultimately killed her. But I guess she thought she could save him. This complete list includes 1883 and 1923. Jamie Bamber is a married man, and his wife's name is Kerry Norton. The death of a sibling . When taking Garretts corpse to the train station to dispose of it, Beth catches Jamie in the acting and takes a photo of Jamie holding his dads corpse as evidence flor blackmail. Strong theory and great insight. Yellowstone fans were surprised when Elsa Dutton (played by Isabel May) was brought back to narrate the 1923 prequel. John has one biological grandchild, Tate. Jamie killed the reporter he had done the tell-all interview with about John to squash its release after she refused. I have my own theories, but its to be told, to be written, to be seen. As with Johns wife, Evelyn, who only appears a handful of times, Johns relationship with arguably one of the most important women in his life remains unexplored. There is something key in whomever their mothers are that is central to the resolution of the series. However, the show has not mentioned the exact reason for her death. Furthermore, she could have sunk into depression caused by the grief leading her to suicide. Yellowstone: TV series starring Kevin Costner from director/writer Taylor Sheridan. I do think potentially that his mother worked on the ranch and that bio dad may have been a ranch hand and therefore the Duttons felt some responsibility for taking him in. I feel like that is a whole lane that can have secrets in . However, before Jamies history is finally told in full, fans are holding out hope for the survival of the rest of the family after a horrific series of attacks in the final moments of this years finale. John Dutton clearly was close to Jamie's birth mother well before Jamie was born," the Redditor explained. Though she did not succumb immediately, Evelyn died within a few hours.[1]. His crimes against Beth seem to be leading to an inevitable showdown with his adoptive sister. .css-g0owdm{display:block;font-family:Memphis,Georgia,Times,Serif;font-weight:normal;margin-bottom:0.625rem;margin-top:0;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}@media (any-hover: hover){.css-g0owdm:hover{color:link-hover;}}@media(max-width: 40.625rem){.css-g0owdm{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.2;}}@media(min-width: 40.625rem){.css-g0owdm{font-size:1.125rem;line-height:1.2;}}@media(min-width: 61.25rem){.css-g0owdm{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.2;}}Kelsea Ballerini Confirms Relationship With Chase, See Lainey Wilson's Stunning Billboard's Look, Carrie Underwood Shares Hilarious Fashion Fail, See Jamie Lee Curtis Jaw-Dropping SAG Awards Look. However, John does not mention his mothers name, and the character remains unnamed after several seasons. He's. John and Evelyn Dutton adopted Jamie when he was just three months old. Monica (Kelsey Asbille) has faced more than her share of tragedy, but she remains devoted to her husband, Kayce, and understands his connection to his family. "John also told Jamie that he begged Jamie's birth mother not to marry Garrett Randall because John knew what kind of man Garrett was. U/Matthmil hypothesized the story behind Jamie's mother is similar and that his birth mother is quite possibly a Dutton herself. Tate (Brecken Merrill) has grown up during the 5 seasons of Yellowstone, and he is the future of the Yellowstone ranch. an inevitable showdown with his adoptive sister, Jon Snow's (Kit Harington) "Game of Thrones" reveal. The Real Housewives of Atlanta The Bachelor Sister Wives 90 Day Fiance Wife Swap The Amazing Race Australia Married at First Sight The Real Housewives of Dallas My 600-lb Life Last Week Tonight with John Oliver. Yellowstone occasionally features flashbacks to the '90s, showing John Dutton and his wife Evelyn with their kids, Jamie, Beth and Kayce. John loved his wife and her wishes to adopt him. We are led to believe that John takes boys in because of Rip but in this instance, Jamie is adopted and given the Dutton name. It would be nice if Yellowstone surprised with the adoption revelation bringing John and Jamie closer together. Jamie will come crawling back, cry, and be accepted back into the family before the end of season 4. Season 5 airing Sundays on Paramount Network beginning November 13th, 2022. Garrett is an ex-con who killed his wife and Jamie's mother, a woman suffering from a drug addiction, when Jamie was a child, as Looper explains. The ugly truth is they want the land, and if they get it, it will never look like our land again. Yellowstone season 4's ending lights many fuses. Yellowstone viewers are unlikely to know unless a dream sequence around such a scenario were to get dramatized. In Season 1, after local Native American chief Thomas Rainwater (Gil Birmingham) threatens to start a land war with the Duttons, Beth promises her father, John (Kevin Costner), that she'll keep the Yellowstone ranch in the Dutton family no matter the cost. Taylor Sheridan's creation has expanded to include the Dutton family origin story with 1883 and 1923, and with new installments (1883: The Bass Reeves Story and 6666) on the horizon, we don't expect the world to be simplified any time soon. He confronts his father about the topic and eventually meets his biological father as he discovers who he really is. Jamie went off to do just that when his father talked him down. An immigrant herself, Cara faced off with fellow ranchers and shepherds while standing in her. Yellowstone Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. Its like a part of her soul just left when her mother died. Jamie Bamber and Kerry Norton seemed together in the Making Friends episode of the 2003 BBC series The Human . You can unsubscribe at any time. Garrett was arrested in 1980 and convicted for the murder of his wife, Jamie's mother. He buried Evelyn on the ranch. "Strong theory and great insight. A few times when John is angry with Jamie he says something like, if I hadnt promised your mother or if I didnt love your mother so much Anyway guess we will fibd out (I hope)! My personal opinion is that John may be blinded in some ways concerning how he has genuinely treated Jamie. And because it was a favor for his wife, he was given better treatment than Rip when he was a kid. Yellowstone is an American neo-Western drama television series created by Taylor Sheridan and John Linson that premiered on June 20, 2018, on Paramount Network.The series stars Kevin Costner, Luke Grimes, Kelly Reilly, Wes Bentley, Cole Hauser, Kelsey Asbille, and Gil Birmingham.The series follows the conflicts along the shared borders of the Yellowstone Ranch, a large cattle ranch, the Broken . During a moment of Beth's hesitation, Evelyn was bucked off her horse. Garrett spent 30 years in jail for murdering Phyllis and Jamie spent that time being raised by John and Evelyn Dutton. He made that connection official when he married Beth. We are led to believe that John takes boys in because of Rip but in this instance, Jamie is adopted and given the Dutton name. How it's immoral that you live here,work here, grow their food here. "When he married the woman who gave birth to you, we begged her not to do it because we knew," said John in season . Similar to how Beth took in Carter and Rip had to deal with it, that is how Everlyn went about Jamie. She was addicted to drugs (not far from Beths problems with alcohol), ran off with Garrett Randall, was disowned by Johns father, and eventually murdered by Garrett. Season 1, Episode 1 of Yellowstone captured the tragic death of John Dutton's oldest son, Lee (Dave Annable). I dont know how to explain the chemistry of attraction, the thing that drives us to k*ll ourselves..